Minor Scale - Discordant Notes

Blog MOVED to Minorscale.net

2005-02-21T00:58:00.000-05:00

This blog has now MOVED to Minor Scale.

Ah! the lure of Wordpress!

47th Grammy Awards 2005

2005-02-14T00:45:00.000-05:00

More photos taken from my Hi-Def TV: Flickr: Grammy 2005

Strangely enough, the award I applauded for the most was not even presented tonight. It was Best Compilation Soundtrack Album For A Motion Picture, Television Or Other Visual Media won by Zach Braff for Garden State. Other than that, it didn't transcend beyond the usual awards show. The usual faces won. Same old speeches & increased applause for the more popular dead musicians mentioned during the In Memoriam segment. Death, alas, is not the great leveller! In fact, Rick James received more applause than Jerry Goldsmith, thanks to Dave Chappelle.

What I remember from the show:

- Bono from U2 performed a song in memory of his father, who was apparently an opera singer. Then went onto mention that he believed he had inherited his father's tenor voice. The song even had the lines You're the reason the opera is in me. Huh?
- Prince was not present to receive his award. Thank God!
- Penelope Cruz said Led Zeppelin was all about great rok. Spoken like a true Mallu, Pene-mol. Oh wait, aren't you Spanish?
- Rock 'n Roll can be dangerous & fun at the same time, said Billie Joe Armstrong, lead singer of Green Day. Profound.
- Matthew Mcconaughey added an extra note to his Texas twang while introducing the Southern Rock tribute segment. Nice job, cowboy!

Complete Winner List: GRAMMY.com

Yuvan Shankar Raja's Raam

2005-02-13T15:29:00.000-05:00

Starring - Jeeva, Gajala // Direction: Ameer
Listen to Raam @ Raaga.
Raam - Official Website (Flash required)

Jeeva, true to his name, is defying an early death to his career and making a comeback with this movie. And maybe a weird hairdo is what Jeeva needs now to salvage his career(!). Of course, his Dad, Super Good Choudhary also has something to do with this, but atleast this time father/son picked a director with atleast one hit to his credit. Raam will be former Bala assistant, Ameer's second venture after Mounam Pesiyadhae. And he has decided to stick with Yuvan Shankar Raja for the music. Apparently the music is hot in Madras, atleast according to Sify.com

Aaraariraaro - KJ Yesudas

The song starts off with a flute, chants and synths leading into a typical Yuvan rhythm we've become used to. But when Yesudas begins to sing Aaraariraaro, it suddenly reeks Ilaiyaraaja. Not vintage Ilaiyaraja, but like one of those latter-day tunes he dished out occasionally for those P.Vasu types. Some would still find the song haunting, but it did nothing for me. Minus all the forced synth sounds, it ended up being a very normal song. Not the best "lullaby" song I've heard. And Sify.com had the balls to compare this with Amma Endru from Mannan. Wha...?!! {3.5/10}

Boom Boom - Yuvan Shankar Raja, Jyotsna, Premji, Tippu

A very familiar synth melody starts off this song soon followed by some top-of-the-line catchy gibberish sung by Yuvan(or is that Premji?). But then, gibberish is the in thing these days, so why not? After the chorus singers pile on the gibberish for some more time, Tippu begins singing about Britney Spears and I swear I heard Norah Jones in there too. But whatever Tippu sang triggers off a brief interlude, upon which Malayalam import Jyotsna enters the fray, strangely sounding like a modern-day LR Eswari. And even though there is only female voice mentioned in the credits, I could swear it was another girl singing the Kadal Thaandum Nadhigal Naangal part, which actually sounded a lot more like the Mallu Jyotsna. So was the first voice just another version of Jyotsna's voice after being extracted through a software plugin? Or maybe Premji is actually a typo for Premaji. I was still pondering this, when the song suddenly took on some distorted Bhangra style notes and ended. So there's the song for you. Confusing as shit, if you start to think about singers or lyrics, but catchy overall. Will soon be playing on every stereo in Madras until it dies a deserved death 6 months from now. {4/10} for now.

Manidhan Solgindra - KJ Yesudas, Vijay Yesudas, Ranjith

The opening lines Manidhan Solgindra Kaayangal Enna? Bramman Undaakkum Maayangal Enna? establishes the sober mood of this song. The chendai is suddenly fashionable these days and alongwith the veenai, Yuvan starts off a nice sounding interlude finished off by the chanting of the Jnaana Karma Sanyasa Yoga from the Gita. The song has only one charanam but with the long drawn out interludes & music it stretches out to 4:39. As for the song itself, I still have mixed feelings about it now. I'm not sure how original sounding it was. Plus my silly self had to immediately draw comparisons with an earlier Yuvan composition from Nanda, Or Aayiram Yaanai, which I thought was very good. Ah well, still the best in the album until this point. {4.5/10}.

Nizhalinai Nijam - KJ Yesudas, Yuvan Shankar Raja

Bad sounding, loud synths start off this song but quickly gets into the pallavi where Yesudas, again, starts singing a nursery rhyme type melody and Yuvan follows it up with some Rahman type yodeling. The song doesn't get anywhere in the remaining 4 odd minutes and continues to disappoint. {3.5/10}

Vidigindra Pozhudhu - Madhumita

Madhumita's turn to sing the female version of the previous song. Not sure if it made a difference. And not sure why anybody thought this song deserved to have two versions. {3.5/10}

Yaaro Arivaal - Madhu Balakrishna

Madhu Balakrishnan's voice I love. It's got a certain quality that was missing from even Yesudas until this point in the album. And how sad is that?! Minimalistic music fills in the track for sometime until some wavy lead synths combined with almost a full-blown Panchavadyam and some heavy brass finish off the song. Short track, but leaves an impact. {5/10}

Elephunking Raja

2005-02-09T02:19:00.000-05:00

Last night I was telling a friend how some remix enthusiasts had gone to work on a relatively obscure Ilaiyaraja song, layered it with some Black Eyed Peas music and rechristened it the Elephunk Theme. Well, how stupid did I feel today when I discovered that the "enthusiasts" were the Black Eyed Peas themselves, this year's 4-time GRAMMY nominated hip-hop group.

After Dr.Dre's experiment with Bappi Lahiri's Thoda Resham Lagta Hain ended in a lawsuit, maybe someone told BEP to lay off Indian composers. The song from the Rajinikant starrer Sri Raghavendra, of all movies, called Unakkum Enakkum Aanandham was originally on their album, but for some reason, seems to have been pulled out from later releases.
As for the remix itself, only S.Janaki's vocal track has been retained, alongwith Raja's funky bass from the original. Guess the fascination is only for female Indian vocals. Poor Malaysia Vasudevan!

For the curious few, this is what S.Janaki is singing about. (mp3: Unakkum Enakkum)

Ikkuchakaangu Ikkicha Ikku Chakkangu Chaan
(Verily Verily I say unto you, Blah Blah Bleh Blook)
Unakkum Enakkum Aanandham Dham, Vidiya Vidiya Sondham
(You & I will find hap-hap-happiness by dawn)
Padukkai Araiyil Aarambam-bam, Pudhiya Pudhiya Inbam
(In the bedroom beg-begins, newfound pleasures)

Do not doubt my translation skills, the lyrics are actually that pedestrian.

Super Bowl bares Rahman

2005-02-07T02:22:00.000-05:00

Well, not a visual treat like the Janet Jackson episode from last year, but a disappointing auditory revelation about the source of one of his song bits.

Damn the Internet. Atleast that's what Indian composers must be saying everyday. Plagiarism in Indian music, which for a long time was kept under wraps & unleashed on an unknowing audience, has been coming to light over the past some years. You hear a song that sounds vaguely familiar and 1/2 times, a combination of Google & some file sharing technology leads you to the source without too much effort.
Like today, while watching one of those Super Bowl ads for Diet Pepsi, I heard a song that immediately triggered off warning bells about a AR Rahman song from not so long ago. For what its worth, the tune I heard did not make up the entire song, rather it figures during the final 20-30 seconds of the title song from Daud. But it sucked for me personally because that was probably the favorite portion of the song for me.

For anyone interested, here is the Pepsi ad - it's the first song, the "la la la" tune heard when the girl opens the bottle
Different District | Movies :: iPod + iTunes - 2005 Pepsi/iTunes Ad (Streaming Video).
Downloadable link

Title song from Daud:
Available as streaming audio from Raaga or final 30 odd secs available for download from here .

And finally, the source of both these tunes.
Fiddler on the Roof - If I Were a Rich Man (vocalist - Topol)

Update (Feb 08):
For any more emotional Rahman fans who'd like to clutter my already messed up comments-section.
Daud - Released in 1997
Fiddler on the Roof - Original Broadway Release, 1964
- And just so you know, I like Rahman as much you do. But plagiarism, in any form & by any composer, cannot be given another name. Sorry, but that's how it is.
- If I think Rahman is going to find and read this little blurb on the Net AND be "disappointed", then I must be the most deluded person on the planet.

Mohana & Sindhu in China

2005-02-04T21:57:00.000-05:00

AR Rahman says in this news article,

"My previous film was 'Warriors of Heaven and Earth'. This is a Chinese film. I had to fly between Chennai and London to complete the film's re-recording. Chinese people like Mohana raaga. I had composed most of the tunes based on this raga and on Sindhu Bhairavi. They loved the tunes," he said.

Interesting. Some googling ensued & revealed the following information about Mohana from this site.

Gamakas for all swaras. Found in Chinese, Japanese and Swedish music

Ilaiyaraja, from what I've read, is sometimes called Mohana Raja considering that many of his songs have been in this raagam. Some of my favorites:
Malargalil / Singer : SP Shailaja / Movie: Kalyanaraman (1979)
Meenkodi Thaeril / Singer: KJ Yesudas / Movie: Karumbuvil (1980)
Naanoru ponnOviyam / Singers: SPB, P.Susheela and S Janaki / Movie: KaNNil theriyum kathaigaL (1980)
Poovil Vandu / Singer: SPB / Movie: Kadhal Oviyam (1982)
Vei Vela Gopemmala / Singers: SPB, SP Shailaja / Movie: Saagara Sangamam (1984) [in Tamil, Vaan Pole from Salangai Oli].
and arguably, the best one:
Ninnukori Varanam / Singer: Chitra / Movie: Agni Natchathiram (1988)

I'm sure MSV has also some gems in this raagam, but from the songs I know about, the best one has to be Kamban Yemaandhaan / Singer: SPB / Movie: Nizhal Nijamaagirathu (1978)

Now, if only someone could come up with a list of Great Mandarin Hits in Mohana & Sindhu Bhairavi.

The Bulla mystery

2005-01-30T13:43:00.000-05:00

Rabbi Shergil's Bulla Ki Jaana Mein Kaun is apparently the desi mantra these days. While I don't understand what the song actually means, and I don't care, the first line interpreted itself to my retarded poetic sense as Yo Bulla dude, listen up yo. This might sound stupid, er...but I really have no frickin' clue who I might be *hic*. An useful mantra, if you really think about it. Imagine a scene at the coffeeshop where a frustrated girlfriend poses the mind-bender,"So, who ARE you, Rahul? Kaun Ho Tum?". And you respond. heh-heh. Main Kaun Hoon? Hum Aapke Hain Kaun? Sholay sahin pikchar tha na? But I digress.Hold on, while I reach for my guitar. What I mean to say is this. Bulla Ki Jaana Main Kaaaaaaunnn".

The song is infectious though. Atleast the first 3 times you listen to it. An average song, at best. But dost being infectious a good song make, me lord? Apparently, yes. And in this age of bad Bollywood music and talentless hacks churning out remixes by the dozen, a music-starved audience lapped it up. So while I stand here on the outside, trying to rationalize this phenomenon, I'm still mostly surprised that this Sardar has enchanted an entire nation with his deep Sufi shit. Oh yeah, and a pinch of good music.

Garden State OST

2005-01-29T20:11:00.000-05:00

Yeah, I know...its already 2005 and I'm talking about a soundtrack that by now adorns the CD rack of anyone with good taste. But then, watching the movie again on DVD brought back not-so-distant memories. And I cannot stress enough on how essential this CD is for your OST collection. Zach Braff of Scrubs fame might look like someone who draws energy from nursery rhymes, but in compiling this soundtrack has shown remarkable maturity in taste. Personally, it was not just the joy of discovering artistes like The Shins, Iron & Wine and even Frou-Frou, but also the thrill of seeing eternal favorites like Nick Drake and trip-hop favorites, Zero 7. And even though, I'm not too big on Thievery Corporation, their Lebanese Blonde is a song that'll make it on Side B of one of my trip-hop compilations. Throw in some Simon&Garfunkel, Coldplay etc. and voila! there's my near-perfect OST.

Nino Rota's 8½ & The Godfather

2005-01-29T19:13:00.000-05:00

The recurring theme in Federico Fellini's 8½ contains a fragment which, strangely enough, just over 8½ years later would form the crux of the haunting theme in The Godfather. I started watching 8½ without really knowing who the composer was, and the theme got me curious and led me to Nino Rota. Isn't it nice that it worked this way? The composer guiding me through his creations.
Speaking of Nino Rota, his background score in Lost in Translation was actually borrowed from La Dolce Vita, one of the earlier Fellini movies. You see, Nino Rota died in 1979. Probably Sofia Coppola's tribute to the man who breathed life into her father's creations.
And on another note, Anu Malik shamelessly plagiarised the Godfather theme for his song Raja Ko Rani Se Pyar Ho Gaya from the movie by the same name. My heart bleeds for you Nino!

Prem Joshua demystified

2005-01-24T12:39:00.000-05:00

Tales of a Dancing River-Prem Joshua

Life is just a river, a long river-Each River, small or big, dissloves into the ocean.

I hope to God Prem Joshua didn't come up with that description, cos' really, its the most retarded thing I've ever read.
So who is Prem Joshua? Apparently, an exponent of Indian Fusion, who's had atleast three albums to his credit. So, I decided to check out his debut album - Tales of a Dancing River. His debut album...should be good right? Not. Let me sum up the music as succintly as I can. If you have seen atleast five FIilms Division documentaries on an exotic place (for some reason, Ladakh comes to mind), then you've already heard his music. First of all, the album is not even remotely fusion, but just santoors, flutes, sitars in random disarray. Oh yeah, and special effects like sounds of thunder cos' The Rains have come (Track #2). Oooooh!
But not all is bad, Track #3, Land of the Buddhas, showed some promise, until I realized the beautiful intro that had me hooked in the beginning was the actual song. The entire song comprises of the same intro looped a million times. And by minute 4:41, I had tired of it.

to be continued...

Vidyasagar's Ji

2005-01-23T13:54:00.000-05:00

JI--> Starring: Ajit, Trisha Director:Lingusaamy
Listen to Ji @ Raaga

Ding Dong Kovil Mani - Madhu Balakrishnan, Madhusree

While songs of yore like Aalaiyamaniyin Osaiyai or Kovil Mani Osai made vague references to the Kovil Mani, no lyricist until now has ventured to offer clarification on what it actually sounded like. Enter Pa.Vijay who breaks new ground in Tanglish Onomatopoeia thus answering the question once and for all. It goes Ding Dong people...Ding Dong.
Madhu Balakrishnan seems to be the singer of choice for Vidyasagar's recent classier compositions like Vizhiyum Vizhiyum (Sadhurangam) or Kanaa Kandaenadi (Parthiban Kanavu). Right from his debut effort in Edhilum Ingu (Bharathi), Madhu B. has done justice to all his songs, both in style & pronunciation. But the same cannot be said of his co-singer, Madhushree, the AR Rahman discovery from Aytha Ezhuthu. Thanks to Maniratnam and/or Vairamuthu, her singing in Sanda Kozhi had less Hindi and more Tamizh. But in Ding Dong, she massacres the song, esp. in the saranam where she seems to challenge us Chris Tucker-like, "Do you understand the words comin' outta my mouth?". And what is with Tamizh composers not caring about the words coming out of their singers' mouths?
The song is by itself a decent composition with subtle beats and neat orchestration. The chendai in the first interlude is a first in Vidyasagar songs that transitions into neat flutes complimented by the veena. The chord shift from sattru munbu nilavaram to endhan nenjil kalavaram is very pretty. The second interlude is nothing much to write about but doesn't hinder the song's safe passage into the final minutes. {6/10}

Kiliyae Kiliyae - Udit Narayan, Sujatha

I wouldn't even bother to write about a song that started off kiliyae kilyae kiliyakka, kizhinju pOchu blah-blah-ka. The last part was lost on me as Udit Narayan decided it was best left for me to guess what he had spat out. But what starts out as a run-of-the-mill Vidyasagar beat-paatu springs a surprise in the saranam which rescues the song from disappearing into depths of mediocrity. Esp. the part where Udit goes vittu kudu blah-blah kodu...its the sole saving grace of this song which otherwise has nothing to offer but maybe an involuntary reaction to break out into dance if you're sufficiently drunk. {4/10}

Thiruttu Rascal - Mano, Sreelekha Parthasarathy

Nice intro. No, really. A lead/bass guitar loop, a rowdy vocal going yaayo, background male vocals going dheem thara dheem thara dheem thara, all soon joined by a happy ghatam resulting in a really funky intro. But that's where you need to hit the Stop button. At 00:35 seconds. Sreelekha Parthasarathi of Kalyaanam Thaan Kattikittu (Saamy) fame does all she can to redeem this song along with poor Mano. But sadly enough, all hope was lost when she went Thiruttu Rascal. :( {2/10}
Deja Vu: At 2:25, when Srilekha goes yaeni(?) pOttu yen manase, it sounds suspiciously like the part ammayappan kangalukku from Akkuthe Akkuthe (Nilaave Vaa), another Vidyasagar song.

Sarala Kondaiyil - Karthik

Probably the brain-child of some ass on the Ji team. Saar..andha Brindhavanamum Nandhakumaranum saang-e eduthu, summa lyrics ulta panni, punniya lyrisk pOtta, super-a irukkum saar. And that asinine idea resulted in this song bit. Thankfully its only a bit and for that, I'll give it an extra 0.5 {0.5+0.5/10}

Vambae Velaikku - Kay Kay

vamba velaikku vaangum vayasu da, ulaga uranda gOli size-da begins this tortorous journey into what only seems like one of those lame hero-intro songs. And the thought of Ajit gnashing his teeth and dancing with a constipated expression is the only thing more scary than this song. *puke* {0.5/10}